BROADCASTING28 MINNOV 10 2026

What aliens tell us about humanity
Rob & Caitlin
Listen
Summary
Aliens in science fiction are invented by humans, so they're built from our fears, hopes, and blind spots. In this episode, Rob and Caitlin start with the alien everyone loves, Rocky from Project Hail Mary, then try out a five-part way of sorting fictional aliens: healer, evil empire, corruptor, victim, and unknowable. Along the way they talk about the tragic misunderstanding at the heart of Ender's Game, the strange language of the heptapods in Arrival, what E.T. asks about recognizing someone's humanity, and why Avatar's colonialism metaphor is a little on the nose. They wonder whether real aliens would be more like the unreachable ocean of Solaris, whether first contact would go well at all, and how Star Trek turned Cold War fears into Klingons. Then they flip the question: what would aliens find strangest about us?
Chapters.
- Favorite aliens: Rocky vs. Ender's buggers
- Arrival's heptapods and the five kinds of aliens
- Aliens as mirrors: E.T. and Avatar
- The truly unknowable: The Expanse and Solaris
- Are we alone, and would first contact go well?
- Star Trek's Cold War aliens and popcorn aliens
- What would aliens think of us?
- We're already alien to each other
Key ideas.
- Aliens are mirrors. Because humans invent them, fictional aliens say more about us than about anyone out there.
- Five kinds of aliens. Healer, evil empire, corruptor, victim, unknowable. Some, like the buggers of Ender's Game, move from one category to another.
- Metaphor vs. truly unknowable. Some aliens stand in for "the other," like Avatar's colonialism allegory. Others, like Solaris's ocean, may be beyond understanding.
- First contact hinges on communication. From Ender's buggers to the heptapods of Arrival, the danger is often misunderstanding, not malice.
- Not every alien has to be deep. In Edge of Tomorrow, the aliens are more obstacle than mirror, and that's fine for a popcorn movie.
- We're already alien to each other. Middle names, textured walls, and diverging languages show how strange humans might look from the outside.
Works we discuss.
- Project Hail Mary, Andy Weir
- Ender's Game, Orson Scott Card
- Arrival, directed by Denis Villeneuve
- "Story of Your Life", Ted Chiang
- E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, directed by Steven Spielberg
- Avatar, directed by James Cameron
- Star Trek, created by Gene Roddenberry
- Solaris, Stanisław Lem
- The Three-Body Problem, Liu Cixin
- "First Contact", Murray Leinster: the story Caitlin couldn't name at 15:17
- Edge of Tomorrow, directed by Doug Liman
- Galaxy Quest, directed by Dean Parisot
Also mentioned: The Expanse, Avatar: The Last Airbender, Groundhog Day, Alan Rickman's Snape, "We Come in Pieces: The Alien as Metaphor" by Daniel M. Kimmel (Clarkesworld, April 2010), the source of the five alien types
Terms we use.
- First contact: stories about humanity's first meeting with an alien intelligence, and the misunderstanding, fear, or wonder that follows.
- Hive mind: a collective intelligence in which many bodies share one mind or will, often modeled on bees and ants.
- Unobtainium: a joking name for an impossibly rare or perfect material a story needs but can't actually get.
“Aliens at this point are invented by humans. So they come from human fears, human desires, human anxieties, blind spots, what have you. And they really say more about humanity than they're saying about alien culture.”
Caitlin (07:14)
“We're just so alien to each other that we don't know how to say we come in peace.”
Rob (15:10)
Start here.
New to sci-fi aliens? Start where both hosts did: Rocky. He's both Rob's and Caitlin's favorite alien, and back in Episode 1 they named Project Hail Mary the place to begin. If you want aliens who are truly different from us, Caitlin's pick is the heptapods of Arrival, adapted from Ted Chiang's novella "Story of Your Life". Ender's Game was one of Caitlin's very first introductions to science fiction and is still a favorite. And if you want something lighter, Rob calls Galaxy Quest "so silly and so, so good."
Transcript.
Lightly cleaned from the final-cut transcript: filler, false starts, and back-channel "mm-hmm"s removed, and names corrected. Nothing reworded.
00:00 Favorite aliens: Rocky vs. Ender's buggers
- Rob
Welcome to SciFi High Five, the friendliest conversation in all of science fiction.
- Caitlin
We're your hosts, Caitlin Jacobs and Rob Skidmore, and today we're discussing what do aliens tell us about humanity, because the aliens are maybe more human than you might think. So let's start with an easy question. Who is your favorite alien? And why is it Rocky?
- Rob
It's Rocky, because Rocky is the best and...
- Caitlin
The ultimate.
- Rob
The ultimate, and I just want to give him a little Rocky hug. Who is your favorite...
- Caitlin
Okay, give Rocky a hug.
- Rob
...and why is it Rocky?
- Caitlin
Also Rocky. It is. He just really is so lovable. I think it's probably the fist bump, you know, the bump my fist. Is that what it is?
- Rob
It's fist my bump.
- Caitlin
Fist my bump. That's right. It's probably fist my bump that does it for me, you know? He's great. I just love the idea of an alien that we're collaborating with and that you come to love so much that you're willing to sacrifice your own future to go save his future, you know.
- Rob
Yeah, I think Rocky is what I would hope that an alien encounter would be like, but we have plenty of examples of that not being the case.
- Caitlin
Yeah, unfortunately.
- Rob
I think my favorite example of aliens that are not like Rocky would probably be the buggers from Ender's Game and the Enderverse.
- Caitlin
Yeah, okay. I love Ender's Game. That was one of my very first introductions into science fiction and still a favorite for sure. So let's hear it. Tell us about the buggers in Ender's Game.
- Rob
I think they're just super interesting because when they appear they are the enemy, and the whole point of the battle school that Ender is in is to train to destroy the buggers.
- Caitlin
Annihilate them, yeah.
- Rob
Annihilate the buggers. And spoilers, if you haven't read it or I guess seen the movie...
- Caitlin
You've had like twenty-five years though, so that's on you.
- Rob
You've had plenty of time. But it turns out this is just a giant misunderstanding. And Ender ends up destroying the entire civilization of the buggers based on this misunderstanding and this inability to communicate.
- Caitlin
It's tragedy.
- Rob
It's a tragedy, and it's an interesting and nuanced take on aliens. Do you have a favorite that maybe is not as huggable as an anthropomorphized rock?